8 Best potato mashers for non stick pans, scratch free mash

When looking for the best potato masher for your nonstick surface pan choosing the right masher material is essential. You should avoid using stainless steel mashers on your nonstick cookware. Since scratching your nonstick pans can cause PFOA chemicals exposure, I went on a quest to find the best potato mashers for nonstick pans that don’t scratch the nonstick surface.

Now, let’s take each of these potato mashers and compare them to help you decide which one is the best fit for your nonstick pots and pans.

Best potato mashers for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Best nylon potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Farberware 5211438 Professional Heat Resistant Nylon Meat/Potato Masher

The Farberware masher is a multifunctional tool that can mash potatoes or other foods like a pro. It chops and mashes your food up evenly. You can use it for mashing potatoes, vegetables, tomatoes, fruits, or even chopping ground meat. 

The masher and the handle are sturdy. It is very well constructed, and the nylon material lasts a long time. Since it is not that easy to mash potatoes, this masher is well constructed to withstand meshing pressure. It is also very well heat resistant.

The affordable price and flexibility in usage make it a perfect masher. Users say that because of 5 tapered blades, it does a great job with less effort. When it comes to the handle, this handle is a perfect size.

It is thicker on the top where you hold it, making it ergonomic for a perfect grip. It doesn’t bend under pressure, and your hand doesn’t slip when the steam from potatoes makes the handle wet. 

A lot of users say that this masher is also perfect for braking up hamburger meat. The nylon coating on all the blades will protect your pan when you break up the ground meat in the searing process. The same goes for mashed potatoes. The nylon material doesn’t scratch the nonstick surface, thus making your cookware scratch free.

Most people say that it is a lot easier to use this 5 blade Farberware masher than a wooden mallet or metal spatula, which can easily scratch your pan.

PROS 

Multifunctional tool
Mashes and chops
5 tapered blades
Heat resistant
Dishwasher safe
Ergonomic handle
Nylon coated
Safe for nonstick cookware and pans

CONS

Needs a prewash if you made mashed potatoes, before putting it to the dishwasher.

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Alternative #1 nylon potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

OXO Good Grips Nylon Potato Masher

The OXO good grips potato masher is a classic nylon masher that does a great job of mashing potatoes. The nylon coated head will protect your teflon or nonstick pans and cookware.

It does not scratch the pan’s surface, and you can use the masher in cold or hot cookware.

If you want your potatoes to be creamy and soft, this masher is for you. It is sturdy, doesn’t require much strength for mashing, and is also well designed to quickly make mash potatoes. You can also get a good grip, which makes the usage effortless. The tines are sharp, which helps with mashing, but at the same time, you don’t scratch the nonstick surface of your pan.

People mention that the oxo nylon masher utensil is robust, comfortable, and useful. Users also mention they use this potato masher utensil for mashing tomatoes, strawberries, and even boiled vegetables.

Some users say that the space between the tines is a bit small, which makes it more difficult to clean.

PROS

Nylon material for scratch free mashing
Dishwasher safe
Non-slip handle
Heat resistant
Use for potatoes, other vegetables, and fruit
Safe for nonstick cookware and pans
Sturdy and strong

CONS

Hard to clean 
Expensive

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Alternative #2 nylon potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Calphalon Nylon Potato Masher Utensil

This non-scratch potato masher is designed with a rounded bottom. This allows efficiently mashing of cooked potatoes. It is also designed to reach into the edge of almost any size and a curved shaped pan.

The handle is large enough and textured for a soft touch and secure grip. It doesn’t bend under pressure and can handle heat up to 400F. 

The nylon material of this potato masher utensil will protect your nonstick pans and pots. It doesn’t make scratches on the pans nonstick material, and with its rounded design ensures minimum rubbing against the nonstick materials.

You can use it for mashing potatoes and other soft vegetables. Mashing tomatoes can be a bit challenging as the masher’s holes can get clogged relatively quickly with tomato pieces.

Users mention that this potato masher has perfect spacing between the holes and that the potato doesn’t get caught up in the masher. It works as great as a metal masher and, at the same time, protects your nonstick pans.

Some people mention that mashing is different with this masher and that there is a learning curve. Most mashers are flat in design, but this one is rounded, and you need to get used to mashing potatoes in rocking motion. The masher is sturdy and dishwasher safe, which makes mashing potatoes an easy task.

A few users reported that the handle is a bit short and that you need to work on the potatoes if you want to get the fluffy and smooth texture of mashed potatoes.

PROS

Full lifetime warranty
BPA free materials
Non-scratch potato masher
Great for potatoes and other soft vegetables
Heat resistant to 400 Degree F/204 Degree C
Dishwasher safe

CONS

Handle a bit short
Learning curve

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Best silicone potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Zulay Potato Masher with Premium Silicone-Coated

This masher has the sturdiness of the fully metal masher with the protection needed for non stick cookware.

It is a hybrid of stainless steel and silicon. It is also labeled as the masher for expensive cookware. This non-scratch masher comes with a thick, protective, silicone coat. Durable silicone coating ensures you always get smooth and fluffy potato mash while keeping your favorite pots and pans secure and scratch-free.

The handle and the body is made of stainless steel. This allows a perfect balance to give the best grip & ultimate comfort when mashing. When you mash, it does not flex or bend.

The silicon coating allows you to mash directly inside your pots and pans, so you don’t need to transfer the potatoes into a separate bowl to protect the non stick coating.

The Zulay potato masher comes in three beautiful colors, ruby red, sky blue, and sunny yellow.

It is perfect for mashed potatoes, which you can make with ease. You can also use it for cauliflower and other cooked vegetables or even raw soft fruits like strawberries. 

Cleaning is effortless because of the silicone coating. After you mash the potatoes, you simply rinse it under tap water and put it in the dishwasher. The stainless steel and silicone are dishwasher safe, which makes for effortless cleaning.

Some people mention that it is an old fashioned masher that everybody loves but perfectly upgraded with a silicone coating for non-scratch mashing.

PROS

Very easy to clean
Heat resistant 450F to 500F 
Very sturdy
Non-scratch potato masher
Food grade silicone
Hybrid of stainless steel and silicone
Firm grip handle
Perfect for potatoes, soft cooked veggies, and soft fruit
Three colors to choose from
Stylish and practical
Sturdy and perfectly balanced handle
Comfortable to hold and use

CONS

A bit big

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Alternative silicone potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Dairy Blue Potato Masher – Nonstick Silicone

The alternative to the Zulay masher is Dairy blue potato masher. It’s an all silicone potato masher that protects your non stick pans and teflon cookware.

With a comfortable handle, it ensures easy mashing of potatoes and other soft vegetables and fruit. Some people mention that it takes a little muscle to mash perfect potatoes, but it is worth it in the end.

It is surprisingly sturdy because of the all silicone construction. It doesn’t bend under pressure even if you are mashing a large batch of potatoes.

This masher comes in three colors blue, green, and red. You can use each color for different food type, blue for potatoes, green for other vegetables, and red for ground meat. 

This masher is not only useful for mashing potatoes, but you can also use it to mashing or cut ground beef and different soft vegetables and fruit.

Once you have finished cooking with the potato masher, you can put it into the dishwasher or hand wash it. Before putting it into the dishwasher, it is better to rinse it first. 

PROS

Non-scratch potato masher
Three colors to choose from
Affordable price
Beautiful design
great mashing ability with less effort
Dishwasher safe
Comfortable handle
Long handle for large pots

CONS

Some sharp spots spotted on a mashing plate

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Best plastic potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Premium Heat Resistant Masher

This plastic potato masher and meat chopper is an excellent tool if you want to protect your non stick and teflon cookware while mashing your food.

Beautiful and practical design, the Zulay Masher is an excellent choice for any home cook. It quickly turns potatoes into a fluffy mash with perfect consistency.

It’s a versatile tool that can not only be used for mashing potatoes but also ground meat, avocado, or even food for your baby. The masher and chopper has four blades, which allows for effortless mashing of potatoes, cooked vegetables, and any other soft food types.

Because of the plastic material, it is very sturdy and durable. It is also dishwasher safe, and cleaning it takes no effort at all. Because it doesn’t have holes, very little food is stuck on it after mashing. A simple rinse before you put it in a dishwasher is enough.

You can easily use this masher while cooking as it will not scratch your teflon or non stick pan. Because of the plastic material construction, your pans are scratch safe.

Most users say that it has a comfortable grip handle that allows easy mashing and chopping. Many users mention that it is excellent for use in an instant pot. You can use it while sauteing meat, before setting up the pressure cooker.

Most users also say that the masher is sturdy, heat resistant, and easy to wash. 

PROS

Very affordable price
Great value for money
Great for instant pot
Non-scratch potato masher utensil
Fits comfortably in the hand
Easy to clean
Dishwasher safe
Comes in many attractive colors
Versatile

CONS

The handle could be a little longer

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Alternative #1 plastic potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Joseph Joseph Delta Folding Potato Masher

This masher is something else. It is very functional. You could say it is a flat masher, but it actually has a locking collar that folds the masher for easy storage, allowing more space in the utensil holder.

It is made from the stainless steel shaft and plastic/nylon mashing plate and handle. The mashing plate has a curved triangle design that allows effortless mashing in curved bowls.

The handle is specially designed for a good grip. It is not as sturdy, but it can handle mashing large batches of potatoes effortlessly.

The holes on the mashing plate make very fluffy mashed potatoes. The cleaning part is a bit more challenging as the potatoes get stuck in them. It’s also a bit difficult to pound it against the pot to get rid of the potatoes in holes because you might damage the folding mechanism.

That is why it is best to rinse it under water immediately after you stop mashing. You can easily put it in a dishwasher after you rinse it under tap water.

The plastic/nylon mashing plate is also perfect to use in nonstick pans. The material will not scratch your non stick surfaces. The masher is also heat resistant, so you can even use it while sauteing your meat or right after the potatoes are cooked. 

PROS

Folds for easy storage
Curved mashing plate for all pan sizes
Dishwasher safe
Heat resistant
Can be used for vegetables and other types of foods
Thick and durable stainless-steel
Comfortable to hold and use
Will not scratch nonstick surfaces

CONS

Expensive
The locking mechanism at the folding angle sometimes comes loose while mashing

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

Alternative #2 plastic potato masher for nonstick surface pans and cookware

Joseph Joseph Easy-Mash Plastic Potato Masher

Don’t let the plain and simple design of this masher full you. This is the only D-shaped potato masher in our review, and the cheapest one. You really get an excellent value for your money with this masher.

It is very easy to hold, which makes it more efficient to use. The grip is non-slip, and it fits into hand very comfortably. It is very sturdy and durable. The curved mashing plate allows for mashing in a variety of pans.

It is made of plastic, that is why it doesn’t scratch the surface of your non stick pans and other cookware. 

You can mash any soft food with this masher, but most users say that they get the best result when they make mashed potatoes. It is also dishwasher safe and heat resistant.

PROS

Inexpensive
Great if you have large hands
Dishwasher safe
Heat resistant
Can be used for a variety of foods
Will not scratch nonstick surfaces

CONS

Harder to cut and mash ground meat

>>Check the latest price on Amazon<<

What material should potato mashers be made of to use in a non stick surface pans and cookware

Traditional potato mashers are made from stainless steel. These mashers are sturdy and durable. But more and more home cooks and family kitchens use nonstick surface cookware. Nonstick cookware is easy to use and is perfect for any type of dish. 

When it comes to mashing potatoes or mashing and cutting ground meat in a nonstick pan, you should be very careful with what kind of masher you are mashing your food. Nonstick surfaces are easily scratched, so it is essential to use a material that doesn’t scratch the non stick surface. 

The article from Scientific American explains the concerns home cooks might have about scratched nonstick pans: quote “Most nonstick pans are coated with polytetrafluoroethylene, also known as Teflon. And there are a lot of rumors out there that Teflon might be toxic and that these pans may not be safe to use.” You can check more on this on their post.

Usually, wooden, silicone or plastic spatulas are used for cooking in nonstick pans. But when it comes to mashing, you need a sturdy masher that doesn’t easily break or bend and is heat resistant to mash those hot potatoes. 

The most common potato masher materials used for non stick pans and cookware are nylon, silicone, and plastic. These materials allow cooks to easily mash potatoes or any other vegetables or fruit in a non stick or Teflon pan, without the sacrifice of scratching the surface.

Nylon, silicone, or plastic materials are all heat resistant and put in a dishwasher after use. The heat resistance also allows home cooks to use the mashers between the cooking process, such as instant pot while sauteing the meat or in a large cooking pot full of boiled potatoes.

Should you consider buying an electric potato masher

Mashing potatoes with manual mashers is relatively easy. You can use a potato masher, ricer, or a sift. 

But all these processes can be time-consuming, and you are left up with gadgets to wash up.

But if mashing potatoes with hand gadgets is too hard or you mash a lot of your food, you should consider getting an electric potato masher. Electric potato masher usually comes with a power base and a masher attachment, which you can use to get that silky, velvety mashed potatoes.

Electric mashers are an excellent substitute for a manual masher. An electric potato masher is a versatile machine that can also process other dishes, like soups and gravies. 

If you want to take all the hassle from mashing your food, you should check our post on the best electric potato mashers to ease the mashing process.

Sources:

Scientific America https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/are-nonstick-pans-safe/

* The prices for ingredients and products in our tables are average prices take from various websites. The prices are not taken directly from Amazon. 

* Pro family chef utilizes affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of our product links, Pro family chef will receive a small commission at no cost to you. This helps support us, and allows us to keep providing tips, reviews, guides, and content for you.